Posted by
Brendan Daly on Monday, June 04, 2007 5:08:25 PM
I grew up with the understanding that abortion was just
another option people had when a condom broke or the pill didn’t work, without
really putting any though to it. I now
firmly believe ANY abortion after 20ish weeks is murdering an unborn
child. Viability at 25+ weeks is now so
good that terminating a pregnancy voluntarily removes the life from an infant
that could be delivered and cared for by adoptive parents.
My personal view is even after 10-12 weeks an abortion is a
hard sell. Enough of the brain, heart
and other systems have formed to make it an ambiguous argument as to a sentient
life being formed.
The problem with the whole abortion issue is the way the
parties are defining the only two viable positions. Pro-life or pro-choice. Where pro-life means ZERO abortions and
pro-choice means any where, any time for any reason. This forces candidates in the middle to align
into basically 50/50 split on the subject.
You get stances like “I’m pro-choice” or “I support the woman’s right to
choose” or “I support the law as written” BUT!!!! I personally oppose abortion.
I think the break down really 3 positions. To the first two (typically religiously held
zero abortion and typically liberal anytime anywhere) and a third (most of
moderate/realistic America)
that is: Abortions should be legal up to X point in time and then illegal. While people can debate exactly what the X
point in time should be, it centers around what is going on inside the
womb. Some would argue brain and heart
(week 10-12 first trimester). Some would
argue any chance of viability (currently week 21.4). Some would argue reasonable viability (week
24-26 second trimester).
In looking ahead, I see a day where third trimester
abortions are illegal in all but the most rare circumstances. The standard political clap trap of “except
for rape, incest or life of the mother” just doesn’t pass the smell test
anymore.
Rape: If you have
carried a fetus to 27 weeks already after a rape and haven’t made the decision
to end the pregnancy, its just plain wrong.
Carry to term, induce or have a c-section and let a loving family have
the child.
Incest: Ditto
above. Even in incest, pregnancies the
rate of defect aren’t prohibitively high and vary in degree. Baring an actual diagnosis of serious genetic
issues, an abortion based on chance for defect alone should be decided far
sooner.
Life of Mother: While
a nice platitude, has been perverted to health of mother and any thing from a
potentially fatal clot to a diagnosis of depression can be used as reason to
end a child’s life.
Roe vs. Wade: Bad
law. Should be overturned. States should regulate and/or the congress
and senate should write a law based on the acceptability of the people they
represent. I dare say it would look a
lot closer to my views of available, but limited.